Head-to-Head Comparison
Nike · Race Super

Alphafly 3

88
Nike Alphafly 3
Stack40mm
Weight218g
Drop8mm
Puma · Race Super

Fast-R Nitro Elite 3

88
Puma Fast-R Nitro Elite 3
Stack40mm
Weight170g
Drop8mm

Key Differences & Advantages

Dead even (88 PTS)

Why choose Alphafly 3?Buy Alphafly 3 if

+0.8 Upper Comfort & Lockdown

+0.8 Upper Comfort & Fit: More secure midfoot lockdown and step-in comfort.

Why choose Fast-R Nitro Elite 3?Buy Fast-R Nitro Elite 3 if

+0.4 Weight Efficiency

+0.4 Weight Efficiency: Better measured rating in wear-test consensus.

The Runner's Pick

Final Decision: Who Buys Which Model?

Side-by-side selection criteria grounded in verified mechanical specs

Nike Alphafly 3
Nike

Alphafly 3

88
Choose the Alphafly 3 if:

Choose the Alphafly 3 if your priority is plush step-in collar padding and irritation-free lockdown powered by ZoomX with two forefoot Air Zoom units paired with a carbon plate (218g). It is the better match for runners targeting friction-free blister prevention across long endurance sessions over the Fast-R Nitro Elite 3's focus on high-mileage protection and low-impact recovery cruising.

8mm drop · 218g · $295Audit
Puma Fast-R Nitro Elite 3
Puma

Fast-R Nitro Elite 3

88
Choose the Fast-R Nitro Elite 3 if:

Choose the Fast-R Nitro Elite 3 if your priority is an ultralight chassis with effortless turnover powered by NITRO ELITE nitrogen-infused PEBA foam paired with a carbon plate and a noticeably lighter weight (170g vs 218g). It is the better match for runners targeting minimizing leg fatigue across late-mile splits over the Alphafly 3's focus on neutral support and surefooted stride containment.

8mm drop · 170g · $300Audit
!

Dealbreaker Warnings · Who Should Skip These

Critical biomechanical trade-offs to avoid buying the wrong shoe

Nike Alphafly 3

Skip Alphafly 3 if your typical workout calls for a specialized racer rather than a durable daily trainer.

Puma Fast-R Nitro Elite 3

Skip Fast-R Nitro Elite 3 if your typical workout calls for a specialized racer rather than a durable daily trainer.

8-Axis Telemetry Radar

Dead even · 88 PTS

Alphafly88vsFast-R88
CushioningEnergy ReturnWeight EfficiencyStabilityTractionUpper ComfortBreathabilityDurability
🔬 Inspect Granular Lab Specs & Fit Telemetry▼

Fit & Sizing Consensus

Real-world wear-test consensus across runner foot profiles

Alphafly 3
Fast-R Nitro Elite 3
Sizing LengthSizing differs
Runs Small
Alphafly54%
True to Size
Fast-R80%
Runs Large
Alphafly 3: Runs small — consider 0.5 size up(n=28)
Fast-R Nitro Elite 3: True to size(n=28)
Toe Box WidthMatch
Performance Tight
Standard
Alphafly57%Fast-R76%
Wide
Alphafly 3: Standard width(n=26)
Fast-R Nitro Elite 3: Standard width(n=24)
Arch SupportMatch
Flat / Low
Alphafly72%Fast-R70%
Neutral Stability
High Arch
Alphafly 3: Flat / low arch(n=22)
Fast-R Nitro Elite 3: Flat / low arch(n=19)
Nike Alphafly 3 vs Puma Fast-R Nitro Elite 3 — eight cohort-calibrated radar axes scored one to ten. Delta is Alphafly 3 minus Fast-R Nitro Elite 3; positive favors Alphafly 3. Score provenance: v1.0, data vintage 2026-10-25. Meta-Score weights score band names.
RADAR AXISAlphafly 3Fast-R Nitro Elite 3Δ DELTACOHORT RANK
Cushioning & Softness9.59.7−0.2 (Fast-R Nitro Elite 3 higher by NaN)#4/23
Energy Return & Bounce9.89.9−0.1 (Fast-R Nitro Elite 3 higher by NaN)#4/23
Weight Efficiency9.59.9−0.4 (Fast-R Nitro Elite 3 higher by NaN)#4/23
Stability & Support6.66.4+0.2 (Alphafly 3 higher by 0.2)#4/23
Traction & Grip7.47.8−0.4 (Fast-R Nitro Elite 3 higher by NaN)#4/23
Upper Comfort & Lockdown9.08.2+0.8 (Alphafly 3 higher by 0.8)#4/23
Breathability9.39.30.0 (dead even)#4/23
Durability4.84.80.0 (dead even)#4/23
Meta-Score88elite88elite0.0Calibrated

The Record · Specification Telemetry

Cohort-relative percentiles and verified technical specs

Alphafly 3
Fast-R Nitro Elite 3
Weight (US Men's 9)Lighter than 96% of daily trainers
Alphafly 3218g
Fast-R Nitro Elite 3170g

›Puma Fast-R Nitro Elite 3 saves 48g per stride, noticeable after mile 6 of continuous running.

Heel Cushion StackMore underfoot foam than 58% of trainers
Alphafly 340.0mm
Fast-R Nitro Elite 340.0mm

›Both models deliver identical vertical impact clearance.

Heel-to-Toe DropΔ 0.0mm
Alphafly 38.0mm
Fast-R Nitro Elite 38.0mm

›Both shoes share an identical 8mm drop geometry for balanced biomechanical loading.

Midsole Foam & Energy ReturnHigher rebound than 97% of tested foams
ZoomX with two forefoot Air Zoom units9.8/10
NITRO ELITE nitrogen-infused PEBA foam9.9/10

›NITRO ELITE nitrogen-infused PEBA foam yields a springier, high-rebound toe-off compared to ZoomX with two forefoot Air Zoom units's grounded, stable feel.

Outsole Durability & TractionTougher rubber than 50% of road shoes
Fast Shot rubber (forefoot and lateral heel patches)4.8/10
PUMAGRIP rubber4.8/10

›Alphafly 3 utilizes Fast Shot rubber (forefoot and lateral heel patches) compound formulated for extended 500+ mile abrasive asphalt longevity.

Quiver Overlap

Direct Race Super Rivals

2-Shoe Rotation Strategy

Both models occupy the exact same race super slot on your shoe rack. Rather than buying both, runner consensus suggests picking the lighter Fast-R Nitro Elite 3 (170g) for quicker cadence, or the Alphafly 3 for its ZoomX with two forefoot Air Zoom units ride feel and structure.

Alphafly 3 RoleRace Super Workhorse
Fast-R Nitro Elite 3 RoleAlternative Race Super

Explore Related Showdowns

High-traffic benchmark rivalries and cohort showdowns